What the message means
Guideline 4.2 asks for features, content and UI that take the app beyond a repackaged website. Apple says an app that is not particularly useful, unique or "app-like" does not belong on the App Store, and that an app without lasting entertainment value or adequate utility may not be accepted.
Apple's App Review page describes two cases under 4.2. In the first, the app is a website, unformatted web content or limited web interaction inside a wrapper. In the second, the app offers too little functionality or content for lasting value.
Common causes
- The app is a web view around your website. The App Review page says websites served in an iOS app and limited web interactions do not make a quality app.
- The app is mostly marketing, ads, web clippings, a content aggregator or a list of links (4.2.2). Catalogs are the stated exception.
- The app needs another app to work (4.2.3(i)), or has to download extra resources to work at first launch without saying how big they are and asking first (4.2.3(ii)).
- The app was built from a commercial template or app generator and someone other than the content provider submitted it (4.2.6).
- The augmented reality feature is thin, such as dropping one model into an AR view (4.2.1).
- The useful part is hard to find. The reviewer stopped at a login, an empty state or a landing screen before reaching the feature that makes the app worth installing. Apple does not list this cause; it is our reading of how 4.2 applies to what the reviewer sees.
Fix it step by step
- Write one sentence about what the app does on the device that the website does not. The App Review page asks apps to make the most of the features unique to iOS.
- Build or surface that capability in this version. If the honest answer is "nothing yet", change the product before you reply.
- Our suggestion: move the screens people use most out of the web view. Apple asks for more than a repackaged website and leaves the technology to you. Native screens are one way to get there.
- Get people to the useful part quickly. Remove empty states and landing screens between launch and the core feature, and give the reviewer an account with real data.
- Fix 4.2.3 issues: the app works on its own, and if it must download extra resources to work at first launch, it shows the download size and asks before it starts.
- Decide between resubmitting and appealing. If you changed the product, resubmit with review notes. If you believe the reviewer misunderstood the app, the App Review page describes an appeal to the App Review Board. Give specific reasons, send one appeal per rejected submission, and answer any request for more information first.
Reply in Resolution Center
Resolution Center is the App Review section of your app in App Store Connect. Lead with what the app does and give the reviewer a short path to it.
Hello App Review team,
Thank you for the feedback about Guideline 4.2.
What the app does: [one sentence about the job it does for people]
What it does on the device that a website does not:
- [capability 1, e.g. works offline with local data]
- [capability 2]
What changed in build [number]: [new features or screens]
How to see it:
1. [step from launch]
2. [step]
Demo account: [username] / [password]
Thank you,
[name]Before you resubmit
- You can name what the app does that the website cannot, in one sentence.
- That capability is in this build and the reviewer can reach it within a few taps.
- The app offers features, content and UI beyond a repackaged website.
- The app is more than marketing, ads, links or aggregated content.
- The app works without another app installed.
- If the app must download extra resources to work at first launch, it states the size and asks first.
- The demo account has data, so the reviewer sees the app in real use.